Why I won’t buy and e-reader (but would really like to)

I like the idea of e-book readers. Rather than printing versions of all the journal articles I’ve downloaded over the course of completing a PhD, I save the PDFs on the computer. I’ve transitioned to reading these articles on my screen at home and have a system where I can annotate the articles I’ve read. Simply, I would love the ability to take these files with me and read them places “normal” books are read (reading on the subway or not having to schlep pounds of paper around are especially appealing).

Now ignoring that Amazon’s Kindle looks like a beast, charges you money to upload PDF or Word files (so is quite the closed system and locks you into buying books from Amazon) and isn’t available in Canada, Sony’s reader is starting to look a lot better than it did just a while ago. The reader software was updated in the summer to allow any EPUB, PDF or text document to be uploaded.

Holding me back from buying any e-reader right now is the inability to mark-up documents. For me, annotation is key. Bookmarking is great, but I need some way when I’m reading to be able to mark a page and enter a thought or idea that is relevant to the text on the page. I can do this cheaply now when I read a book with a highlighter and a pen, but missing from that system is the searchability that my digital workflow allows: I can search for a term and up pop all the academic articles that have it

Just unveiled yesterday, however, is Plastic Logic’s entry into the market and it appears to be a marked improvement on Amazon’s and Sony’s readers:

Drool-worthy is the flexible touchscreen (missing from Sony & Amazon) and Wi-Fi connectivity (Kindle does connect to Sprint’s network in the states–but this is why, in fact, you have to pay to upload your documents to the Kindle. No one rides for free on cell networks). It also supports the ability to upload the regular suspects in terms of document files.

This product’s killer app is mentioned at 1:14 of the video above: the ability to mark-up documents, with drawing and text. If Plastic Logic is able to successfully integrate these features, this will have the potential to be an incredible device for my own digital academic workflow.

So, I wait with baited breath to hear more about this device.

3 replies on “Why I won’t buy and e-reader (but would really like to)”

This was all over the e-book blogs yesterday. Looks like a nice enough device, if they can get the DRM right. (Don’t hold your breath for DRM-free e-books, sadly. It’ll take a long time.)

The iRex iLiad (stupid iWannabe name) already does annotation and wi-fi. It just costs too much and can’t handle ePub.

@ Jack

That iLiad looks nice and the ability to annotate is sweet, but you’re right: at $699 US, you begin to enter into laptop territory.

Oh, and it’s interesting to note that the iRex website is horrible at outlining just what the difference is between the iLiad “2nd edition” and the “book edition” (other than price).

The “book edition” omits the wi-fi.

Most e-book manufacturers have pretty lousy marketing abilities. I mean, there’s one out there called the Astak. Pronounced Ass-tack. Who green-lighted that one?

It might be three more generations before you’d use at a price you’d pay. Heck, my Sony reader is essentially a paperweight at this point. Good thing I didn’t spend money on it. Though I may bust it out this fall so that I can have some compact reading on my travels. If I can ever find that &@#$(&$#*( AC adapter.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: