• Academic Homepage
    • Educational Development Portfolio
      • Statement of Educational Development Philosophy
      • Artifacts and Evidence
    • Teaching Dossier
      • Statement of Teaching Philosophy
    • Multiple Acts of Birding: PhD Research

Gavan P.L. Watson

A website proudly muddying the line between my private and public persona.

dichotomous key

Giant Hogweed vs. Cow Parsnip vs. Water Hemlock vs. Wild Carrot

July 14, 2010 by Gavan 20 Comments

The Toronto media is ablaze with reports that Giant Hogweed (Heracleum mantegazzianum) has been found within the borders of the GTA. Normally, when an invasive species is found, it does not generate this kind of buzz. Why the hubbub? The sap of Giant Hogweed, on the skin, can lead to a severe skin inflammation called phytophotodermatitis. Many people, however, don’t know how to identify Giant Hogweed or know how tell it apart from Cow Parsnip (Heracleum maximum), a native species (and only somewhat phototoxic).

With the caveat that you should have an knowledgeable plant person confirm any identification, let me quickly outline how you figure out if that plant is Giant Hogweed or something else.

The confounding factor here is all four plants above have white flowers in an umbel (a botanical term to describe the arrangement and shape of the flowers—I’ve included an illustration of what an umbel structure looks like below).

Flower structure: Umbel

Giant Hogweed Dichotomous Key

So beginning with the assumption that you have a plant with an umbel of white flowers in the GTA, you can try your hand at identification with this key. Please be aware that this key will only work with a mature plant, and Giant Hogweed can take two years to reach the flowering stage. The key is dichotomous, meaning that you will be given two choices. Answer each question with one of the provided choices, go to number and you will come up with an identification.

1: Look at the flower.
If it is 15 cm in diameter (measured from flower edge to flower edge) or larger, go to 3
If it is 14 cm in diameter (measured from flower edge to flower edge) or smaller, go to 2

2: Good news! A small flower means that this is probably not Giant Hogweed. When mature, Giant Hogweed will have flowers up to 1 meter in diameter. It could be Queen Anne’s Lace or Water Hemlock. Note that Water Hemlock is extremely toxic if consumed.

3: Look at the stem of the plant. Is the stem reddish or purple, with spots and stiff bristles?
If yes, go to 4
If no, go to 5

4: This plant is probably Giant Hogweed. To confirm, have a look at the flower. Giant Hogweed has flowers with over 50 rays (a part of the flower structure which I’ve illustrated above). Cow parsnip will have between 15-30 rays.

5: Good news! This plant is probably Cow parsnip. It will have fine hairs, but no stiff bristles. The stem may be purplish, but is mostly green with no blotching or spots. Keep in mind that Cow Parsnip is phototoxic, too.

Keys to a Giant Hogweed ID

Just in case you hate the idea of a dichotomous key, or have questions about a non-flowering plant, here are the key differentiators between Giant Hogweed and other similar-looking plants:

  • large plant, often over 2.5 m high (when mature)
  • flowers in umbel shape, larger than 15cm in diameter
  • flowers have more than 50 rays
  • hollow stems are between 3-8 cm in diameter
  • stems have stiff white bristles
  • stems have spots or blotching, red or purple in colour
  • large, lobed leaves up to 1m in size
  • leaves compounded in three
Posted in: Nature Tagged: cow parsnip, dichotomous key, giant hogweed, plants, Toronto, water hemlock, wild carrot

About me

Gavan Watson headshot Work life? Director, Centre for Innovation in Teaching and Learning & Associate Vice President, Teaching and Learning at Memorial University with a Ph.D. in environmental education. Home life? Father, naturalist, photographer, husband, philosopher, & member of a hybrid human-dog pack.

Latest tweets

My Tweets

Flickr Photos

Cross Orbweaver SpiderlingsNorthern Gannet, on nestBog LaurelFemale Blackpoll with nesting materialGoldthread flowerMetallic beetle on Leatherleaf
More Photos

Keyword Cloud

Academia Academic Alaska birders Birding Birds blog Conference cupe 3903 Dissertation Environmental Education ethics Flickr goals handwriting higher ed house sparrow How-to learning map migration Natural History Nature note taking ontario photograph Photography presentation reflection research Review rondeau solution spring strike Support Teaching teaching assistants Technology Toronto twitter upgrade wordpress york strike york university

Archives

Meta

  • Log in
  • Entries feed
  • Comments feed
  • WordPress.org

Copyright © 2022 Gavan P.L. Watson.

Omega WordPress Theme by ThemeHall